Suno's bigger problem isn't training data: it's whose voice it sells
The Elvis and Eminem suits add a voice-and-likeness front to the training fight, and that makes licensing much harder for Suno to treat as optional.
AI-generated image
What if the most dangerous thing for an AI music company isn't only what it was trained on, but what it sounds like? That is the uncomfortable question Suno now faces after two new lawsuits, and we think it is the most interesting turn in the AI music fight so far.
What happened, briefly
As The Verge reports, a group of rights holders of Elvis Presley's music and the publisher of some of Eminem's biggest records are suing Suno. They claim it generates music and lyrics that mimic those artists. The Presley side invokes Tennessee's Ensuring Likeness Voice and Image Security (ELVIS) Act, a 2024 law aimed at AI voice cloning. According to Variety, the 51-page filing says users can generate tracks that mirror Presley's "rich vocal timbre" without permission. Eight Mile Style, which controls hundreds of Eminem recordings, alleges copyright infringement in its own case.
Suno's answer, given to The Verge, is that it doesn't allow prompts for specific artists' names and songs. It also says it works with third-party providers to screen uploaded audio and lyrics.
Voice is a harder claim to wave away than data
For a long time the debate has been about training: did the model copy songs to learn? The Presley side makes that argument too. Startup Fortune says Authentic Brands Group and Raleigh Music Publishing claim Suno copied 859 Presley compositions. But training is a fight over a process nobody outside the company can see, and defendants can always argue about what counts as learning. A voice is different. It is audible, it is recognizable, and a judge can listen to it. The Presley complaint reportedly leans on exactly that, with examples of the platform producing voices close to his.
That is why we read these suits as the opening of a second front rather than another entry in the pile. Suno already faces cases from Sony, UMG, Reservoir Media and Jason Isbell, among others. The Isbell suit, per The Verge, did not claim copyright infringement directly but argued the plaintiffs were imitated. The new Presley case follows that template, with state likeness law layered on top of the copyright claims.
A licence for the songs may not cover the singer
Here is the part we think the industry is underrating. A deal over catalogs and recordings is, in our reading, a different thing from a likeness right. Startup Fortune makes the same point, saying the ELVIS Act claim is one a Warner-style licence wouldn't cover. If that logic holds, a platform can't buy peace once and move on. It needs clearance for the voice too.
The "we block artist names in prompts" defense also looks fragile to us. A filter on the input box says little about what comes out. Per que.es, the Presley complaint says typing his name was enough to get a clone. We can't verify that, and it is an allegation, not a finding. But if a court takes it seriously, guardrails become evidence to be tested rather than a shield.
What we'd expect, and what to watch
Be careful with the numbers. One outlet, tech-insider.org, says Eight Mile Style seeks more than $41 million over 269 compositions, and the figure is repeated elsewhere. We'd treat it as the plaintiff's ask, not a likely outcome. There is no trial date in the material we have, so any prediction is speculation.
Still, our reading is this: the more suits add "you sell our sound" to "you trained on our songs," the less room there is for the position that licensing is a courtesy. Rights holders who don't have a major-label seat at the table now have a state statute and a pattern of complaints to work with. That is leverage, and independent publishers and estates will probably notice.
The risk for Suno isn't one verdict. It is a map of lawsuits, each testing a slightly different right. The sensible move, in our view, is to negotiate voice and likeness terms before a court sets them. If you follow this space, watch the ELVIS Act claim above everything else. If it survives, AI music's "ask forgiveness later" era could be effectively over.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Lume's album-first bet is a healthy rebuke to singles culture, if it grows
A Lorde-backed app that sells albums instead of renting them is the right counterweight to singles culture, but good intentions won't pay the bills or widen its audience.
McCartney's billion is a publishing win, and touring is the garnish
Forbes puts Paul McCartney at $1.4 billion, and the biggest engine is a publishing company, not a stadium tour. Younger artists who sold their masters should pay attention.
MSG's "limited availability" answer explains nothing, and that's the problem
When a venue says an act that just sold out arenas in three cities is "not an arena level act," it owes the public more than a calendar excuse and a shrug.
Suno isn't fighting lawsuits anymore, it's fighting the catalog owners
Elvis's rights holders and Eminem's publisher have sued Suno. We think the pattern is clear: whoever owns the catalog will set the price of AI music, and Suno will pay it.



