Take That say they're still hungry. Dreamers has to prove it
Take That's tenth album tests whether a legacy act can sell ambition instead of nostalgia, and the early evidence is encouraging but not conclusive.
AI-generated image
"Still hungry" is the most overused phrase in the veteran-band press cycle. Everyone says it, and almost nobody has to prove it, because the stadium tickets sell either way. Take That have now said it too, and their tenth album, Dreamers, is a rare case where the claim can be checked against the songs.
The stadiums are full either way, which is what makes the pitch interesting
The album is due November 20. Ahead of that, Gary Barlow, Howard Donald and Mark Owen presented the new songs at the London Palladium, a theater of roughly 2,000 seats, with a big band and an orchestra. As reported by German outlets including Express, the sold-out crowd was enthusiastic. Donald said they feel blessed to still be around nearly 35 years on "and still hungry to make great music," as the German coverage renders it (our translation).
The context matters. This summer's "Circus" tour drew more than 700,000 fans in the UK and Ireland, so the band doesn't need a new record to fill a venue. That is exactly why the hunger pitch is interesting. Nostalgia is the safe business, and they are choosing to put new songs front and center anyway.
Putting the new songs first is the bold part
Plenty of 90s acts have settled into the same three hits, as the coverage itself points out. The reports say Take That's second set at the Palladium was built mostly on post-2006 hits like "Patience" and "Greatest Day", which means the new songs came first. Presenting fresh material to a room of fans who, in many cases, were hearing it for the first time is a real risk, even if goodwill cushions it.
We think the process matters more than the slogan. According to the same reports, each member started on his own, outside writers and guests came in, and the album was recorded in London, New York, Nashville and Los Angeles. Barlow wrote nearly all the 90s hits alone. Barlow says Donald's disco track "Higher" was the day the album began, and letting a bandmate's demo set the direction is the kind of unglamorous decision that signals ambition. Nostalgia acts protect the formula, and this looks like a band loosening it.
Owen, though, complicates the pitch a little. Krone quotes him saying the debut album was very close to them during the work and that they reproduced much of its fresh, innocent feeling. Is that hunger or a wink at the past? Probably both. We would argue that's fine: ambition and nostalgia aren't opposites, and the trick is using the past as a color, not a crutch.
The songs are good, but "pleasant" is the risk
The early verdicts are warm. The German reviewers talk about hooks, an orchestral opener in "Wonderkids", a slow-building chorus in "You're A Superstar", and a title track with Owen on lead that could become a live staple. That is an early, mostly favorable reading from one press event, and we'd treat it as such. The same coverage calls "Who Do You Think You Are" rather pleasant and "Masterpiece", the Tom Odell co-write, a bit kitschy.
That is the real danger for a mature pop album. "Mature" can mean confident, or it can mean smooth. A record full of well-made anthems can still be forgettable, and the most telling moments in the coverage are the odd ones: a disco lead from Donald, a folk-tinged stomper with Michael Patrick Kelly, a track that vaguely echoes Robbie Williams' "Rock DJ". Those are the songs that suggest curiosity rather than maintenance.
There's also a commercial subtext we shouldn't pretend away. The Kelly collaboration is, as Krone notes, no bad move for popularity in German-speaking markets, and the band is on a new label with a 31-date European tour announced for summer 2027, per Rolling Stone Germany. Hunger and market strategy can coexist, but a reader should notice both.
Our verdict
Take That have earned the right to say "still hungry," and unlike many peers they at least built the evidence into the setlist. But a slogan isn't a result. The test is whether a track like "Dreamers" or "Higher" is still in the live show in two summers, next to "Rule The World", or quietly dropped to make room for the old favorites.
If you've written Take That off as a boyband relic, the early coverage suggests this is worth a listen on its own terms. If you're a fan, ask for more of the strange stuff and less of the safe ballads. That's where the hunger shows.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
GTA VI's 34-song leak shows games are now the biggest A&R desk in music
A leaked tracklist with Playboi Carti, Dua Lipa and Lana Del Rey shows Rockstar acting like a label, and the real test is whether the songs survive without the game.
U2's Carnaval de Luz leans on Dolly and Rosalía. The songs must carry it
A posthumous Dolly Parton duet and a nod to Rosalía make great headlines for U2's first album in nine years. The record will be judged on the songs.
U2 doesn't need Carnaval de Luz to sell. It needs it to matter
U2's first album in nearly nine years arrives with a world tour attached and early reviews split. The songs, not the name, now have to justify the machine.
U2's second Berlin night proves the name sells. The album still has to earn it
A second Olympiastadion date arrived days before Carnaval de Luz drops. The demand looks real, but it belongs to the band's legacy, not yet to the record.



