Deezer says half of new uploads are AI. The scandal is who gets paid
Deezer's CEO says AI makes up half of daily uploads, but the real problem is a payout model that rewards volume, so platforms must label, filter and demonetize.
AI-generated image
Is a flood of machine-made songs really a threat to music? Not by itself. Nobody was ever harmed by a song nobody plays. The real threat is a payment system that treats a track from a human and a track from a prompt as the same kind of lottery ticket, and a lottery rewards whoever buys the most tickets.
That is the uncomfortable core of the alarm Deezer's boss is sounding. As L'Express reports, Alexis Lanternier says half of the new music uploaded every day is produced by AI. The outlet describes it as a tidal wave. It also notes that the way artists are paid on platforms encourages copyright fraud. Lanternier, the piece adds, does not want to ban "non-human" music from the catalog.
A separate report says Deezer will launch an AI music filter, after a survey found user demand for transparency. Few details are public, so we won't guess at how the filter works or when it arrives.
The headline number is a distraction
"Half of uploads" sounds apocalyptic. But uploads are not listening. A catalog can absorb millions of tracks no one hears without any artist losing a cent. What matters is how much of the money, and how much of the recommendation real estate, those tracks capture.
That is why L'Express's framing is the sharpest part of the story: the incentive is the problem. If royalties are drawn from a shared pot, as we understand most streaming payouts to work, every stream diverted to a synthetic track is a stream taken from someone else's share. Fraud then becomes a business model: upload cheaply and endlessly, then hunt for plays. Software has made the first half of that equation almost free. We think any payout system that doesn't price in that asymmetry is, in effect, subsidizing spam.
Banning AI music is the wrong fight
Lanternier's refusal to purge non-human music strikes us as the realistic position, and not just a commercial one. Some listeners will want AI tracks, and some artists will use these tools as part of an otherwise human process. A blanket ban would be unenforceable and would generate endless disputes over where "assisted" ends and "generated" begins.
The better demand is narrower, and it has three parts. Label it, so listeners know what they are hearing. Filter it, so those who don't want it can opt out, which is where the demand for transparency in Deezer's survey points. And demonetize it, at least where it is used to game the payouts. Labels without consequences are decoration; filters without payout reform leave the incentive intact. The three only work together.
The risk is that the burden lands on humans
The most likely failure mode is a detection arms race. L'Express itself describes a race between ever-better AI software and ever-better tools for spotting it. In an arms race, false positives are inevitable, and we'd bet the people who suffer them will be small human artists with no lawyers and no label to appeal on their behalf. If platforms demand proof of humanity, it must be cheap, quick and reversible.
Platforms should also publish what they find. If Deezer can say that half of daily uploads are AI, it can tell us how much of the money flows to them. That figure, more than the upload share, would show whether this is a nuisance or a heist. We think the other big services should be pressed to disclose the same.
Our verdict
Deezer deserves credit for sounding the alarm publicly and for treating transparency as a product feature. But the verdict will come from the payout rules, not from the press tour. If AI tracks keep earning on the same terms as human ones, labeling merely documents the damage. Human artists don't need a ban, only a system in which a million free uploads can't outweigh one real career. Listeners can do their part now: use any filter or label that appears, and treat unlabeled catalog spam as the platform's failure, not theirs.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Jay-Z's $665M "payday" isn't his: the real story is who owns the catalogs
The headline says Jay-Z cashed in $665 million, but the money went to Duetti, a catalog buyer he is tied to through Roc Nation. The real news is Wall Street's appetite for royalties.
Lume's album-first bet is a healthy rebuke to singles culture, if it grows
A Lorde-backed app that sells albums instead of renting them is the right counterweight to singles culture, but good intentions won't pay the bills or widen its audience.
McCartney's billion is a publishing win, and touring is the garnish
Forbes puts Paul McCartney at $1.4 billion, and the biggest engine is a publishing company, not a stadium tour. Younger artists who sold their masters should pay attention.
Suno's bigger problem isn't training data: it's whose voice it sells
The Elvis and Eminem suits add a voice-and-likeness front to the training fight, and that makes licensing much harder for Suno to treat as optional.



